MEDIA COVERAGE

Radio KWLM Talks about city of Watson

 Please click the link below

http://www.youtube.com/user/citynavigators#p/a/u/0/GRDc6doVqLY


Published February 24 2010

Watson votes for change

WATSON — Voters in the small Chippewa County community of Watson voted Tuesday for a change in their city governance structure.

By: Tom Cherveny, West Central Tribune

WATSON — Voters in the small Chippewa County community of Watson voted Tuesday for a change in their city governance structure.

In a special election, voters cast 72 “yes” to 17 “no” ballots for a measure that will make the city clerk and treasurer positions a single, appointed position.

Currently, the city clerk is elected to that position and is a voting member of the Watson City Council. The treasurer is also elected currently, but does not have a vote.

Loisjean Fossen is city clerk and Marcie Radtke is treasurer. Both will continue to serve in that capacity through the remainder of the year.

Fossen said after the count that she would likely retire at the end of her term.

Voters on Tuesday also defeated a measure that would have allowed Sunday liquor sales — 46 “no” to 43 “yes” votes. The Goose Bar had sought approval for Sunday sales.

Watson has a population of just over 200 people.

 

 

Please click the link below to listen to the MPR coverage of Watson City Discrimination issue aired

Feb. 23, 2010

http://minnesota.publicradio.org/display/web/2010/02/23/small-minn-town-in-big-political-mess/

The town of Watson is located about 115 miles west of the Twin Cities. Turmoil in Watson in recent months has led to a vote Tuesday that could remake the city council, but also to civic battles that have all the acrimony of a big-city political feud. (MPR Photo/Mark Steil)
Small Minn. town in big political fight
by Mark Steil, Minnesota Public Radio
February 23, 2010

Copy and paste the HTML below to embed this audio onto your web page.

Audio player code:
<script type="text/javascript" src="http://minnesota.publicradio.org/www_publicradio/tools/media_player/js/swfobject.js"></script><div id="minnesota_news_features_2010_02_22_watson_20100222_64s_player"></div><script type="text/javascript">/*<![CDATA[*/var so = new SWFObject("http://minnesota.publicradio.org/www_publicradio/tools/media_player/s_player.swf", "minnesota_news_features_2010_02_22_watson_20100222_64s_player", "319", "83", "8", "#ffffff");so.addParam("quality", "high");so.addParam("menu", "false");so.addParam("wmode", "transparent");so.addVariable("name", "minnesota/news/features/2010/02/22/watson_20100222_64");so.write("minnesota_news_features_2010_02_22_watson_20100222_64s_player");/*]]>*/</script>

Watson, Minn. — Talk of political gridlock often refers to logjams in Congress or at the state legislature, but it can happen anywhere.

Case in point: the small town of Watson in western Minnesota, where resignations, lawsuits and accusations of incompetence are all part of everyday political life.

The turmoil in recent months has led to an effort to a vote Tuesday that could remake the city council in Watson, which has fewer than 200 residents, but civic battles that have all the acrimony of a big-city political feud.

At one recent city council meeting, emotions boiled over. Watson resident Bev Sailor expressed feelings held by many in town on the performance of their elected officials.

"I'm sorry, I think somebody is being very disrespectful at that table. You guys are elected officials, we pay your salaries," Sailor said during the session, captured in a YouTube video. "And I don't think we deserve disrespect when we come to a meeting."

Residents blame the city council for a series of problems. Some say they're being overcharged on their water bills. They wonder if the city's budget will balance. City Council inaction is hurting the town's development, former mayor Kylene Olson said.

"There's easements that need to be taken care of for the new wastewater and water distribution and collection lines that need to be laid," Olson said. "And that has not been taken care of the way it should be."

Much of her dissatisfaction is directed at City Clerk Loisjean Fossen. Olson said Fossen's poor management has delayed needed progress.

"I don't think she has the capacity that it takes to fulfill the job requirements right now," Olson said.

Today's vote would change the city clerk and treasurer positions from elected to appointed. If voters approve the change, Olson said the council could hire experienced people in the future and avoid a repeat of the current situation. Fossen would be allowed to serve out her term.

Fossen calls the election a vendetta mounted by political opponents who failed to make her do what they want.

"This is a town of few people with such hatred for me," she said. "And they're running me down, they're harassing me, they're belittling my name. And I shake and I'm almost in tears."

Because the clerk's job gives Fossen a seat on the City Council, her vote gives her a powerful role in city affairs.

For her critics, the primary issue is competence. Some residents say Fossen too often refuses to fulfill her duties, such as providing residents with minutes of council meetings. Fossen said she is being blamed by residents who don't follow proper procedure in filing their requests.

At one point, Fossen resigned her position, then quickly rescinded the action. But Fosssen said she won't attend City Council meetings until the mayor and council stop what she calls "citizen abuse."

"Stop letting these certain residents come in and tell us what we're going to do and make insults on me, false accusations," Fossen said. "Because our city business is not getting done. Our City Council meetings [are] a joke."

Fossen's assessment of the council's meetings is probably the only point of agreement between the two sides in the Watson debate.

Mayor Jason Avelsgard at one point also resigned because of the fighting, but he too changed his mind. Then City Council member Kevin Norman resigned. The council has canceled meetings because there weren't enough members on hand to handle city business.

Why the rancor in Watson has grown to this point is not exactly clear, but there's one factor that's unmistakable: a dispute over a vegetable garden. The city sued resident Aziz Ansari alleging the four canopies around his house that cover his vegetable garden violated city zoning requirements.

Ansari, who was born in Pakistan, said the city's action is rooted discrimination.

"There's no reason to believe otherwise," Ansari said. "They are discriminating, they take me as a different person, different religion, and treat me differently."

City officials deny there's any discrimination involved in their lawsuit against Ansari. But the dispute led to a rift in town, which continues to play out at council meetings and now may lead to a change in city governance.

Ansari said Fossun is not the only one to blame, but he hopes changing her job will result in a shakeup.

"I definitely want the system to be changed," Ansari said. "Hopefully there will be a change for the positive."

The Watson uproar has attracted the attention of the FBI. Agents have talked with Ansari about his discrimination claims.

In a separate development, the state auditor plans to review the city's books.

While today's election could settle some questions in town, there's likely more turbulence ahead for the residents of Watson.

Watson voters approve changing form of government


 
By Staff photo by Grayce Ray
While election judge Avis Peterson (left) looks on, election judge Debra Birdsall explains the proper way to fill out a ballot to a voter Tuesday in the city of Watson’s special election. Not shown is election judge Dorothy Gustafson.

TEXT FROM KWLM 1340 am WILLMAR, MN

Watson changes government...Ansari saves couple
02/26/2010 07:47 AM

 
The people of Watson this week have voted to change their form of government. By a 72-to-17 vote on Tuesday, they voted to change from Plan A, to Plan B, meaning the city clerk position will go from being elected to being appointed. That affects city clerk and council member Loisjean Fossen, who will have to give up one of her positions. Grayce Ray of the Montevideo American News says Fossen has indicated she plans to retire when her term is up in November. Ray says Watson also rejected allowing the Goose Bar to have Sunday liquor sales by a vote of 43 to 46. She says it was very cold on Tuesday which may have kept voter turnout down. Ray says it looks like Watson will be filling two city council seats this fall. The turmoil in Watson began when the city ordered resident Aziz Ansari to take down his covered tomato beds, saying they were a building and against code. Ansari has refused, and is now suing the city. Ray says Ansari recently came to the rescue of John and Marilyn Handeen, both 85 of rural Milan who spent 7 hours trapped in their car when it got stuck in a snowbank in a blizzard February 14th. The Handeens kept warm using a candle and by occasionally running their engine. Aziz found them shortly after midnight and had to shovel a path in the snow to get their car door open. Ray says Ansari's first words to the Handeens, once he got the door open, was, "What are you doing here, celebrating a honeymoon?"
By Grayce Ray
Montevideo American-News
Thu Feb 25, 2010, 08:00 AM CST

Montevideo, MN -

Watson residents voted overwhelmingly, 72-17, in Tuesday’s special election, to change the city’s form of government to a Plan A from the current standard form.

What this means is that the clerk and treasurer position will no longer be elected but appointed, and that the city clerk will not have a position on the city council. That seat on the council will be filled by an additional council member after the next general election.

The special election brings to an end a tug of war between residents and the council and clerk which began months ago when residents submitted a petition calling for the change. Since then the clerk and council have delayed setting the date for the election several times.

On Feb. 9, during the regular council meeting, the council voted to have the city clerk available at the city hall on Feb. 16 and 17 from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. to accept applications for absentee ballots. City Clerk Loisjean Fossen was not at that meeting and Mayor Jason Avelsgard took notes.

On Feb. 13, Avelsgard sent Watson residents a letter telling them when, where and at what time the election would be held.

Three days later Fossen sent residents a letter stating that the city office would be open for walk-in absentee voters Feb. 20 from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. and Feb. 22 from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., a requirement of Minnesota Statutes, but she did not refer to the days and hours set by the council vote.

She explained that she did not know about the council’s vote and did not receive Avelsgard’s letter until after she had sent hers. She said Avelsgard had not turned over the minutes of the Feb. 9 meeting although she had left him messages asking for them.

Fossen has said she will not attend meetings until Avelsgard stops the “abuse” she has been subjected to by council and residents. In an interview with Minnesota Public Radio, she said, “Our City Council meetings are a joke.”

Tuesday’s vote will not make any change in the council until the general election in November. Recent council meetings have been marred by resignations tendered and withdrawn from both Fossen and Avelsgard, and one resignation by council member Kevin Norman on Feb. 9. Further resignations would leave the council with only four members and problems reaching a quorum if anyone is absent.

Despite the vote for change, the city still faces a horde of problems; the 2010 budget is still being worked on, the new water meters are still not working satisfactorily, the council has still not set a base rate for water consumption, easements have not been completed for residents who will be getting sewers installed this spring, treasurer’s reports have not been adequately presented in council, and residents want an accounting of city finances.

In addition the city is working through a lawsuit against resident Aziz Ansari for his gardens which the city maintains violate city ordinances, and a second lawsuit against the city brought by Ansari claiming discrimination.

A second measure on Tuesday's ballot to allow the city to issue liquor licenses allowing eligible establishments to sell liquor on Sundays was defeated by a narrow margin of 46 no to 43 yes

 
By Grayce Ray
Montevideo American-News
Thu Feb 18, 2010, 08:00 AM CST
Milan couple spends hours stranded in car

A Milan area couple spent more than seven hours trapped in their car stuck in the snow during Sunday’s whiteout conditions.

John Handeen and his wife, Marilyn, both 85, were en route about 5:30 p.m. from his farm to Milan along a county road when he lost control of the car after hitting a patch of ice under a snow drift and ploughed into a deeper drift at the side of the road. The car was half-buried and would not move, John said Tuesday.

Marilyn said he was determined to walk to his farm to get a tractor, but she insisted that he stay in the car. Marilyn, generally a soft-spoken woman, said “That’s when I got a little demanding. I told him we’d always been told to stay with the car in case of a winter accident, and he was not to leave me alone. We couldn’t even see a yard light in the dark and the snow drifting.

“So then we started calculating how much gas we had and John figured out how long we could run the car on that.”

“I figured we could run the engine for 15 minutes every hour to keep warm,” John said.

Marilyn found candles in the back seat, left from decorating her church at Christmas, and matches. They located a tin can, put a candle in it, lit it and scrounged for anything else that might come in handy. John, a dedicated reader, had some books picked up at the Goodwill and Marilyn hoped he’d have something she’d like.

“With him it’s usually algebra or physics or chemistry, but I found something nice — a book about friendship,” she chuckled. “The candle we’d lit was a scented one, vanilla, and it gave enough light to read and it smelled good and we were warm enough. It was kind of romantic.”

The hours passed, with John running the engine every so often, and they noted that the temperature had risen two degrees from 12 to 14 degrees. Finally around 12:30 a.m. a bright light shone behind their car.

A figure appeared in the swirling snow, shoveling a passage to the front doors of the car.

Aziz Ansari from Watson, a friend of the couple, had been searching for them for about three hours when he spotted the car deep in the drift. When he had cleared a way to the door, he wrenched it open, looked in at the two sitting calmly, lit by candlelight, and his first words were “What are you doing here — celebrating a honeymoon?”

Ansari helped the Handeens into his four-wheel drive truck where their son Paul waited and ploughed his way to John’s farm, then to Marilyn’s in Milan.

John, a survivor of a heart bypass and due for his third pacemaker, has always been a stubborn and self-reliant Norwegian. Early Monday he was out clearing his lane and the county road.

He said Tuesday “I don’t believe in taking it easy. I’m just getting my tractor out to go get the car; it’s still stuck out there.”

His advice after the adventure? “Everybody should carry candles in the car. You can get more heat out of candles than anything. We only used two in all that time. Oh, and be sure to take matches. We were all right. We had three-fourths tank of gas and I figured we could run the car 15 minutes every hour and stay comfortable.”

Marilyn is less blase. “I have never seen that road so deep. It was luck or something else watching out for us. The only reason they knew we were missing is because I didn’t call my son Paul as I always do, and the only reason they found us was because they turned the wrong way.”

Paul, worried when he did not hear from his mother by 9:30 p.m., called Ansari because he knew Ansari and the Handeens had been at a presentation in a Willmar church earlier in the day. Paul has a small car so Ansari insisted on taking his four-wheel truck to look for the missing couple.

The men rushed off with a borrowed cell phone, no shovels and no idea where to look. At John’s farm first, they were stuck in the deep drifts in the lane and scrounged a shovel of Handeen’s to get the truck out.

Ansari said he doesn’t remember how long they shoveled. “The wind kept blowing — we moved the snow and it kept blowing back with the wind in our faces. The four-wheel drive was lifted off the ground by all the snow under it. We took turns shoveling and finally got moving.”

They made their way through blizzard conditions down the farm lane, then made a turn to the west, instead of the east as they had intended. Unable to turn, they continued toward the next cross road.

“By golly, there they were. All we could see was the red glint of their tail lights because it is a white car, half buried in the snow. It had piled up enough I don’t think they could have got the doors open,” Ansari said.

Ansari, a native of Pakistan, said he did nothing unusual in rushing into the night to look for the couple. “I just had to go. God pushed me and I went. We (the Handeens and I) have had more than three cups of tea together, and in Pakistan when you have shared three cups of tea you are family.”

 

Letters to the Editor February 25, 2010


Montevideo American-News
Thu Feb 25, 2010, 08:00 AM CS

Judge by action
I have heard it said, as I believe, that one should judge a person by their actions. I was reading the story in the Feb. 18 edition of the Montevideo American-News about the couple stuck in their vehicle during the recent storm, when a familiar name popped up in the story.

The name was Aziz Ansari of Watson. This man had spent three hours and risked his own safety to search out this stranded couple. He also brought their son with him to help. This speaks volumes about the character of Mr. Ansari.

This is the same gentleman whose vegetable gardens caused the city of Watson such consternation. I have seen him labled as a troublemaker and as causing a blight on the city of Watson.

I suggest he is none of these things, as illustrated by his selfless behavior in finding his friends who were lost in the storm.

This incident should show the perspective of what Mr. Ansari is trying to do in Watson. I think the city should be proud to have someone like Aziz Ansari living in their community, rather than keeping an ongoing battle with a man growing vegetables.
—David Dvorak
Montevideo

  1. Milan couple spends hours stranded in car

    A Milan area couple spent more than seven hours trapped in their car stuck in the snow during Sunday’s whiteout conditions.

    http://www.montenews.com/archive/x925448349/Milan-couple-spends-hours-stranded-in-car

    Thu Feb 18 00:00:00 PST 2010

  2. Petitions await action

    Watson residents hoping to see some changes in city government are in for a surprise. Two petitions submitted by residents have yet to see any action.

    http://www.montenews.com/archive/x1802478954/Petitions-await-action

    Thu Dec 17 00:00:00 PST 2009

  3. Information request leads to complaint

    Five Watson residents who Monday asked city clerk Loisjean Fossen for a copy of a city council meeting found themselves facing Chippewa County Sheriff Stacy Tufto on Tuesday to respond to a complaint that they intimidated the clerk.
     

    http://www.montenews.com/archive/x896785205/Information-request-leads-to-complaint

    Mon Nov 2 00:00:00 PST 2009

  4. Sanford Elementary students learn about tomatoes

    All the students at Sanford were given the opportunity to try red and yellow tomato varieties with cornchips and asked to indicate which they preferred.

    http://www.montenews.com/archive/x1991986692/Sanford-Elementary-students-learn-about-tomatoes

    Fri Sep 25 00:00:00 PDT 2009

 

 

 

Watson mayor decides to withhold resignation


By Grayce Ray

Montevideo American-News

Thu Feb 11, 2010, 09:55 AM CST


Montevideo, MN -

In a telephone conversation several days after his expected resignation from office, Wat­son Mayor Jason Avels­gard told the American-News he had decided not to hand in his resignation.

He said several Watson residents had called and pleaded with him to stay on the city council and that he will continue to serve for the time being.

Avelsgard said he would attend the Feb. 9 council meeting. He added that city clerk Loisjean Fossen had informed him she would not be there as she will be on vacation.

At the council meeting Tues­day night, Councilman Kevin Norman submitted his resignation, which was accepted.

The seat will remain vacant for one month while council decides what action to take.

Published February 09 2010

Voters in Watson to decide governance; special election may settle town dispute

WATSON — Voters in Watson will soon have a say in one of the disputes that has divided the community.

By: Tom Cherveny, West Central Tribune

WATSON — Voters in Watson will soon have a say in one of the disputes that has divided the community.

A special election will be held from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. Feb. 23 to decide whether to change the city’s form of government.

Watson council members set the election date and ballots have been printed for the special election, according to Jon Clausen, Chippewa County auditor-treasurer.

The election was triggered by a petition from citizens in the community.

They would like to see the city clerk and treasurer positions combined and that position be appointed.

Currently both positions are elected.

The city clerk also is a voting member of the city council, while the treasurer does not have a vote. Loisjean Fossen serves as clerk and Marcie Radtke as treasurer.

If the petitioner’s proposal is approved by a simple majority of voters, the two officer-holders would complete their terms. At the start of the new year, the council would appoint a person to the position as an employee.

The special election will also feature a second ballot question on whether or not to allow Sunday liquor sales in the community.

The dispute over city governance has also led to two separate petitions asking for a state audit of the city’s books.

A representative from the state auditor’s office will be meeting with petitioners on Friday to determine the scope of the audit.

The citizens who brought the initial petition seeking a state audit have a two-page list of questions they’d like to see answered.

The initial petition was followed by a second petition- this one including the names of current city council members- asking that the period to be audited be extended to cover three prior years.

Chief among the questions raised in the initial petition is a request to know how much the city has spent on legal fees with the Kennedy and Graven law firm of Minneapolis.

The community of 211 people has retained the firm to serve as its city attorney, and the firm is managing the litigation against Aziz Ansari, also known as the Tomato Man for his roadside vegetable stand.

The city has accused Ansari of violating city ordinances by erecting plastic covered, hooped structures on his residential property to raise tomatoes and other vegetables.

Ansari disputes that the structures are in violation of the city ordinances, and has answered the city’s litigation with his own: He filed a discrimination lawsuit against the city charging a number of current and former city officials with discrimination against him as a person of color and Muslim.

The lawsuit alleges that the city has aggressively prosecuted him for alleged zoning violations while ignoring far more egregious violations elsewhere in the community.

Both the city’s and Ansari’s cases are moving forward.

Last month, Ansari answered questions during a full day of deposition.

More recently, defendants in the discrimination lawsuit met with legal staff to prepare answers to questions posed by Ansari in the discrimination lawsuit.

 

 

Watson mayor resigns position


By Grayce Ray

Montevideo American-News

Thu Feb 04, 2010, 08:00 AM CST


Print This

ShareThis

Montevideo, MN -

Citing irreconcilable differences with the city clerk, the mayor of Watson has resigned his office one year into his term.

Former Mayor Jason Avelsgard dated his official letter of resignation Jan. 29 and effective immediately. It will likely be formally announced at the next city council meeting on Feb. 9.

Avelsgard was absent from the last two council meetings and acting Mayor Mark Radtke said at the last meeting on Jan. 28 that he believed Avelsgard had resigned.

Avelsgard said in a phone interview Jan. 29, “The main reason I resigned was our city clerk (Loisjean Fossen). All the things I wanted to accomplish have been undermined by Loisjean. As mayor there was nothing I could do about it.

“I was getting very tired of doing her job. I’ve spent a lot of time and my own money doing the job. I left her phone messages she wouldn’t return. I’ve been working to push through getting easements signed by residents after she tried once and then wouldn’t do any more. I’ve worked to get a date set for the special election and she’s blocked that time after time.”

Avelsgard said he had received a letter from the city attorney warning that the special election could be jeopardized if the city clerk did not take care of her responsibilities regarding the election.

The special election comes after Watson residents signed a petition seeking to have the city’s form of government changed from its current Plan B which has the clerk elected and sitting on the council, to a Plan A which would call for the clerk to be hired and not be a council member.

The city council had failed to set a date for that election since the petition was presented to the council in October 2009. Finally, at the Jan. 28 meeting, the council voted and approved Feb. 23, from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m, for the special election.

Fossen must advertise time and place for voting, send out absentee ballots and appoint three election judges. Chippewa County Auditor/Treasurer Jon Clauson said ballots and equipment will be ready by then.

Relations between Avelsgard and Fossen have been strained for months as evidenced by several outbursts from Fossen during council meetings when she refused to set office hours after Avelsgard and council member Kevin Norman asked her to. She said she was an elected official, their equal, and did not have to take orders from them.

At one point she resigned, then rescinded the resignation and remained on the council. Two weeks ago she said she would not attend any meetings until Avelsgard ran meetings according to the agenda and she was not “abused.”

She attended the Jan. 28 council meeting and said later that she thought her “problem was taken care of,” with Avelsgard’s absence.

During the last council meeting, Fossen made a motion that Radtke go to Avelsgard’s home and collect all documents that belong to the city. The motion was carried but Radtke cautioned that nothing should be done until Avelsgard’s official resignation was received.

Avelsgard said that he believed residents were not informed about city business.

“There’s definitely a look of people not knowing what is going on,” he said. “If Loisjean had resigned I would not have, because then I would have had a fighting chance.”

He said he had no city documents at his home.

City council can now appoint someone to fill the vacancy.

The peasants are revolting


Grace Ray Column

 By Grayce Ray

Montevideo American-News

Thu Jan 28, 2010, 08:00 AM CST


Print This

ShareThis

Montevideo, MN -

Who would be a politician? It’s a dirty job but someone has to do it. Cities and counties, big and small, have multiple issues to deal with. Maintenance of streets and roads, zoning and building codes, health and welfare of citizens, permits and licenses, just to name a few.

In the main, people who run for positions on the councils which govern municipalities are amateurs, willing to give their time and plenty of energy at personal cost for little reward. But seeing a well-conducted city where things run smoothly and residents work together to make it happen is a handsome payment.

Some cities are proud enough of their government to showcase it on local TV, to welcome citizens in to watch it at work, to invite school classes to sit in and see how it operates, to publish minutes of meetings to keep people informed.

This amazing country was founded by a bunch of amateurs, willing to give their time and energy and hopes and with no blueprint for a democracy, but look how well it generally functions.

And no, we don’t all hold hands and sing Kumbayah, but we do hold our hands out to each other in time of need, to help others up, to clap at joyful events, to clasp strangers’ hands so they know they are welcome. And we know many hands make light work.

In the old movies, evil rulers frequently meet their ends when the angry mob comes, armed with pitchforks and torches, and the trusty servant warns, “The peasants are revolting!”

Watson has no peasants but residents are angry. Their elected officials seem to have forgotten that their job is to serve the people, to respect their needs, and to see that the community’s affairs are conducted reasonably.

Squabbling around the council table, sniping at residents who ask for explanations, attempting to keep people away from public meetings, not attending to business affairs in a timely and open manner — none of that accomplishes anything constructive. People who complain that they are being made to look like fools, mostly don’t need any help doing so.

Ben Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, John Adams et. al., were amateurs at building a government and they had no Google or Internet or Wikipedia to consult. So give civility a try. Remember why you ran for office and get on with it. Do the job and you just might get the respect you want.

 

Watson special election date still up in air


 

By Grayce Ray

Montevideo American-News

Thu Jan 28, 2010, 08:00 AM CST


Print This  

Montevideo, MN -

The city of Watson seems to be stuck in a quagmire. A special election requested by a petition from residents in October is still pending. City council members have tentatively set one date after another for that election, but so far nothing has happened.

First, it was supposed to be on Jan. 19, but the council forgot to vote on the matter; next, Feb. 2 was proposed, but council again failed to vote on the date. Now, Mayor Jason Avelsgard has said the election will take place on Feb.23, despite both council meetings scheduled for January having been cancelled.

The Watson City Council seems to be disintegrating. Members are at each others’ throats, the city clerk refuses to attend meetings or keep regular office hours, residents are disappointed and angry, unsure where to turn for information about the city budget, escalating water bills and mounting legal fees incurred in the city’s legal battles with one resident.

The council appears to dodge the issue, cancelling meetings, not showing up for meetings, refusing to make minutes of past meetings available to residents, delaying preparation of a budget, and abruptly terminating meetings rather than answer residents’ questions.

The petition asked for a special election to change the form of government from the current Plan B, which has the city clerk elected and also serving as a council member, to Plan A, which calls for the clerk to be hired and not on the council.

The council finally agreed to contact Chippewa County Auditor/Treasurer Jon Clauson for advice on when the election could be held. Clauson said early February would allow time for his office to prepare the ballots.

Avelsgard said then that the election could take place Feb.2, but council meetings scheduled for Jan. 12 and 19 were cancelled and so no date has yet been set by vote.

Last week Avelsgard said he had again met with Clauson and tentatively set the election date for Feb. 27. Clauson said preparation of the ballots is already underway, and special equipment which will allow voters who are visually impaired or otherwise unable to deal with a written ballot should be ready by Feb. 27. That equipment will use an optical scan ballot as an alternative to marking a regular ballot.

“The process should be transparent to the voters as well as maintaining their privacy,” Clauson said. “I expect the printer and programmer should have the ballots ready for the election February 23rd.”

City clerk Loisjean Fossen did not attend last week’s meeting, which was cancelled for lack of a quorum. When this reporter spoke to her at her home that evening, Fossen said she would not attend any council meetings until Avelsgard assured her she would not be subjected to abuse from him or anyone at meetings and that he would conduct the council meetings correctly and follow the agenda.

City treasurer Marcy Radtke said Avelsgard has not signed city checks for several weeks and that honorary Mayor Mark Radtke has been doing that.

 

 

Watson special election possible Feb. 2


 

By Grayce Ray

Montevideo American-News

Thu Jan 14, 2010, 08:00 AM CST


Print This

Montevideo, MN -

Watson residents could be voting at a special election as soon as Feb. 2 to change the form of government in the city from a Plan A to a Plan B.

The city council has been wrestling with issues around setting the date for the election since Oct 13, 2009, when they were presented with a petition signed by a group of residents asking for the change which would eliminate the city clerk’s position as a council member and call for a clerk to be hired.

Council members discussed a date of Jan. 19, 2010, at an earlier meeting, but did not vote on the matter and the issue came up again and again at later meetings.

Residents who attended a special meeting two weeks ago were adamant about having the council set a date and vote on it. After some heated discussion, Mayor Jason Avelsgaard said he would take the petition to Chippewa County Audi­tor/Treasurer Jon Clauson and get his advice on the earliest date available for the election.

Clauson said his office would not need much time to prepare for the election. His office will need to prepare a roster of the registered voters and prepare ballots.

The city of Watson will have to notify eligible voters by advertising the date, place and intent of the vote.

“They need to set a date and I advised them that sometime in early February would be acceptable,” Clauson said. “Prepara­tion of ballots can be done very quickly now since it’s all automated.”

In addition to the question of changing the form of the council, the ballot will also ask voters to approve or deny granting a Sunday liquor license to the Goose Bar.

A second petition by residents asking for a state audit of books, minutes and transactions by the city of Watson for the past several years is in the hands of the state and no information is available on its status to date.

Residents can expect to see a change in water bills at the end of January when bills will be based on actual usage rather than the old flat rate of $62.

Ever since water meters were installed several months ago, the meters have shown an estimated number of gallons, rather than actual amounts, due to a “glitch” in the computer system. Banyon Data Systems of Burnsville, which installed the meters, has made several efforts to fix the problem, City Clerk Loisjean Fossen said.

The meters are supposedly working correctly now and will be metering actual household consumption. Marcie Radtke, city treasurer, informed residents of the coming change in billing with a note enclosed with last month’s bills.

Fossen said the city paid Banyon for training in programs for the meters and that the company had made several efforts to fix the problem. The city has retained Banyon to maintain the system at a cost of $700 a year.

Fossen said she will ask the company to reconsider charging the city for the repairs.

 


Montevideo American-News 
 
By Grayce Ray
Montevideo American-News
Thu Dec 17, 2009, 08:00 AM CST

Montevideo, MN -

Watson residents hoping to see some changes in city government are in for a surprise. Two petitions submitted by residents have yet to see any action.

The first petition signed by 34 residents called for a special election to change the form of government in the city from the present Plan B which elects the city clerk to also serve as a council member to a Plan A system which has an appointed city clerk not elected to the city council.

That petition was given to the city council by residents on Oct. 13, more than two months ago. Watson City Council members discussed a date for the special election and agreed to hold it on Jan. 19, but they failed to vote on the issue.

Since then the council has taken no action on the petition except to discuss a different date. Mayor Jason Avelsgard said in a telephone conversation this week, “That petition has just been buried. It should not have happened but it did.”

City clerk Loisjean Fossen told council members at last week’s meeting state laws do not allow a special election to be held within 45 days of a holiday. She said Monday this week that she might have misunderstood state laws and had now received new information from the city attorney telling her that the county would need 53 days to set up the roster of voters and prepare for the special election after the council set a date.

Calls to the state auditor and the secretary of state confirmed that there is no provision requiring a 45-day moratorium for special elections.

Watson residents and some council members have repeatedly jousted with the clerk over the lack of set hours when she may be reached and the difficulty of accessing records of meetings and pertinent information about city expenditures.

Avelsgard said Monday he is unhappy with the situation but does not know how it can be changed.

The second petition submitted by residents asked the state auditor to “examine the books, records, accounts and affairs” of the city “covering the period from Jan.1, 2006, to Oct. 30, 2009,” and requested that a copy of the final audit be sent to Watson resident and former mayor Kylene Olson.

Rebecca Otto, of the state auditor’s office, said the petition had been received by the auditor’s office but she could not say when (or if) action would be taken.

Jon Clauson, Chippewa County auditor, received that petition on Nov. 5 and found that it contained the number of signatures required by law to be valid.

Several other issues are unresolved by the council. Fossen had resigned her office last month, but at last week’s meeting Avelsgard told the council she had rescinded that resignation. He declined to discuss the matter until he has the time to discuss the matter with Fossen.

She reported that she has retained her own attorney to advise her on her rights.

The Watson Fire Department Relief Fund, which receives an annual contribution from state insurance companies, has made repeated requests to Fossen for the money which arrived in the city in October, the Relief Fund treasurer reported.

Fossen denied knowing how much the check was for, the treasurer said, and finally the Relief Fund officials appealed to the state. They finally got the money, a little more than $5,000, on Monday, after meeting with Avelsgard.

The money is direct deposited to the city’s account and the city is supposed to hand it over to the Relief Fund. No one seems to know what took so long this time.

The council has not been able to decide how to display minutes of meetings so residents can see them, nor have they acted to set regular hours for the clerk so residents with questions can contact her.

The city and several individuals have been sued by Aziz Ansari on the grounds of discrimination, and they have filed a suit against him charging  that his raised garden beds are in violation of city codes.

The council has not discussed the suit with residents at council meetings, but legal fees paid to the firm of Kennedy and Graven, the city attorneys, so far this year have cost the city a total of $46,888.65.

Some of that expense resulted from charges for services required to install the new water/sewer system in place and $27,371.95 of the attorney’s fees for related issues were paid from the loan/grant the state awarded Watson, Fossen said.

To add further headaches for council members, the new water metering system is still not working properly and residents are still paying the old flat fee of $62 per month for water some months after meters were installed.

Litigation against Ansari and David Brovold, another resident charged with a zoning violation, cost the city $13,331.73 this year, an office memo supplied by Fossen noted.
Other legal expenses Fossen reported to city counsel were $6,184.97 for general city work and $2,318.30 to Richard Ronning, the city’s criminal prosecutor, for two criminal matters.

 

FOLLOWING PAGES ARE SCANED FROM MONTEVIDEO AMERICAN NEWSPAPER

OCTOBER 29, 2009

 

 

 

FOLLOWING PAGES ARE SCANED FROM MONTEVIDEO AMERICAN NEWSPAPER

OCTOBER 22, 2009 

 FOLLOWING PAGES ARE SCANED FROM MONTEVIDEO AMERICAN NEWSPAPER

NOVEMBER 19, 2009

FOLLOWING PAGES ARE SCANED FROM MONTEVIDEO AMERICAN NEWSPAPER

NOVEMBER 19, 2009

 

 

 

 

 

MINNESOTA PUBLIC RADIO COVERAGE OF THE DISCRIMINATION ISSUE

 

 To listen to the radio broadcast about this issue please click the link below.

 

http://minnesota.publicradio.org/www_publicradio/tools/media_player/popup.php?name=minnesota/news/features/2009/09/02/disputeovertomatogardendividestown_20090902_64

 

 

Photo: #Aziz Ansari posted this sign on his property.

Larger view
Aziz Ansari posted this sign on his property. (MPR Photo/Mark Steil)
View full slideshow (7 total images)
Dispute over tomato garden divides town
by Mark Steil, Minnesota Public Radio
September 2, 2009

LISTEN
Copy and paste the HTML below to embed this audio onto your web page.

Audio player code:
<script type="text/javascript" src="http://minnesota.publicradio.org/www_publicradio/tools/media_player/js/swfobject.js"></script><div id="minnesota_news_features_2009_09_02_disputeovertomatogardendividestown_20090902_64s_player"></div><script type="text/javascript">/*<![CDATA[*/var so = new SWFObject("http://minnesota.publicradio.org/www_publicradio/tools/media_player/s_player.swf", "minnesota_news_features_2009_09_02_disputeovertomatogardendividestown_20090902_64s_player", "319", "83", "8", "#ffffff");so.addParam("quality", "high");so.addParam("menu", "false");so.addParam("wmode", "transparent");so.addVariable("name", "minnesota/news/features/2009/09/02/disputeovertomatogardendividestown_20090902_64");so.write("minnesota_news_features_2009_09_02_disputeovertomatogardendividestown_20090902_64s_player");/*]]>*/</script>
sponsor:
Support this program

Watson, Minn. — The town of Watson has long been known around the state as Minnesota's goose hunting capital, but recently the community has received some more negative attention after a spat over city zoning ordinances has grown into a feud that has driven deep divisions through the tiny town.

The rancor in Watson is intense and dates back years. In 2007, the dispute helped convince the mayor to resign mid-term, after 9 years in office. These days, most city officials refuse to comment on even the most basic issues in the case.

They explain they're worried anything they say could inflame the divisions in the town. The root of the conflict is a garden located near the highway that splits the community in two.

The owner of the garden is Aziz Ansari. Surrounding Ansari's house are hundreds of plants in long rows.

"I think I've got plenty of tomatoes," Ansari said. "A lot of green ones and red ones; they're in the thousands."

But it's not the amount of tomatoes or cucumbers he's raising that's the problem. It's the way he's growing them. Ansari built four, raised bed gardens around his house. Each is about 18 inches off the ground, six-feet wide and almost one hundred-feet long.

The beds are extensive, but what really catches the eye are the arched canopies above the plants, making them look like a train of covered wagons. Ansari said the white plastic draped over the curved hoops makes the plants more productive. The vegetables are doing well, but Ansari said he's a little behind in his garden chores.

"I'm bogged down with all the paper work," Ansari said. "Writing letters, to the city attorney, to the court, to different attorneys trying to find somebody who'll represent me."

What's eating up his time is dealing with a lawsuit, scheduled for trial next January, that the city filed a year ago over the so-called hoop gardens. Watson officials say the hoop gardens violate several city ordinances.

The city's main charge is that Ansari needs a building permit for the gardens. They also say city ordinances prohibit a commercial vegetable operation in a residential area.

"It's an illegal lawsuit, it's just trying to harass me," Ansari said.

Ansari said there's nothing commercial about the gardens. He said he gives the vegetables away. Much of the food goes to poor people, who otherwise might not be able to afford it. If someone leaves money for the produce, he gives the funds to a church.

Ansari also said there's nothing in city law that requires him to have a building permit for the hoop gardens. The city said there is: specifically, section 2, subdivision 135 of its zoning code. It requires a building permit for 'anything which is built, constructed or erected on the ground or attached to the ground.' Ansari says that's so vague it's unenforceable.

The judge in the case may be sympathetic to that argument. He wrote "the Court is troubled by the seemingly broad definition" of the ordinance.

Ansari said the lawsuit has a more sinister purpose than enforcing city law.

"They're talking about you can't grow vegetables," he said, "but it's not about vegetables, it's about discrimination, that's what it is."

Born in Pakistan, Ansari said pure and simple the city is after him because of the color of his skin. He said he moved to town to enjoy a peaceful retirement and it's been anything but that. He said while many residents support him, there seem to be a few out to get him. Someone broke a window on his pickup, and another person told him to his face he wasn't welcome in Watson.

"One of the guys, he's on record saying 'go back where you came from'", Ansari said.

Ansari fought back and started a Web site. On it he drives home this point: he's prosecuted while white residents who violate city ordinances -- including some city officials -- are left alone. On a drive around town he pointed out a few of them.

On one block is a boarded up house. A building downtown has bare wood walls exposed. He says the properties violate city laws on blight. Ansari pointed out an old unlicensed truck with no engine. He said that violates a city ordinance on derelict vehicles.

"That is clearly telling that they've got different standards for different people," Ansari said. "They want me to abide by the regulations, [but] when it comes to these people, absolutely no problem."

But if Ansari sees clear-cut discrimination, city officials see nothing but a stubborn trouble-maker. None wanted to be quoted for this story, citing the ongoing litigation. But Mayor Jason Avelsgard did answer several questions.

Avelsgard said the city is not singling out Ansari for racial or any other reasons. He said Ansari is not alone in being sued, a couple of years ago the city took another Watson resident to court. He admits there are other zoning violations around town, but said the city is pursuing enforcement.

Although he and other city officials are mostly silent, the inflammatory allegations being tossed around are the talk of the town.

"Where it really hits me is just seeing the division and the hurt that is going on in the community right now." said Rev. Larry Olson, the pastor of a church in Watson.

Olson said residents welcomed Ansari when he came to Watson. Olson, who's also an organic farmer, said he liked to talk with Ansari about growing food, and when Ansari suffered one of several heart attacks, a Watson resident led the effort to help.

"He and another neighbor who's a member of the congregation actually helped carry him down the stairs," Olson said.

Olson said he hears from both sides in the dispute. He said people who considered Ansari a friend are especially upset by his charges of racism.

"So when the label comes up, there's really kind of a feeling of betrayal," Olson said. "From the earlier welcoming, to now their behavior being called racist."

Olson said the dispute has divided the town and in some cases people acquainted for years no longer speak to each other.

"It was unfortunate that it has blown up to be this type of thing," he said.

To former mayor Kylene Olson, the dispute has been allowed to go too far.

"I, at this point, feel that both sides are wrong," Kylene Olson said.

Olson, who's no relation to Pastor Olson, served nearly five terms as mayor of Watson. One reason she left the job was because of the seemingly unsolvable dispute over the vegetable garden.

She said there's no city ordinance on the books that clearly prohibits hoop gardens. Early on in the dispute, she felt the city should leave Ansari and his gardens alone. But now, she feels Ansari also has gone too far, cramming his yard with vegetable plants just to thumb his nose at the city council.

"And I don't think either side is going to win here," she said. "I don't know what's going to happen."

What is clear is that both sides are dug in deep. The two parties have exchanged settlement offers, but so far haven't come close to an agreement.

If the past is a predictor, the feud could escalate more.

Just recently, Ansari raised the tensions another notch. He put up a sign on his property, right next to the highway. The headline on the board says "Stop Discrimination". For now at least, Highway 7 is not the only thing dividing this tiny west central Minnesota town.

 

 

 

Please click the link below to listen and/or read the MPR report.

 

http://minnesota.publicradio.org/display/web/2009/09/02/tomato-man-watson/

 

 

 

 

Account | Logout      Friday, August 14, 2009
West Central Tribune
text size: zoom out zoom in     print article Print     e-mail article E-mail     ShareShare
Published August 13 2009

Table set in Watson for legal fight; city wants producer to dismantle growing area, citing a violation of city ordinances

WATSON — The red-globed tomatoes that Aziz Ansari raises are ripe for the picking, and his cucumbers ready for the slicing.

By: Tom Cherveny, West Central Tribune

RELATED CONTENT

WATSON — The red-globed tomatoes that Aziz Ansari raises are ripe for the picking, and his cucumbers ready for the slicing.

The table in Watson is set for a legal fight.

The city of Watson is going forward with a lawsuit that would require Ansari to dismantle the four hoop structures in which he raises his roadside produce along Minnesota Highway 7 in this community of slightly more than 200 people.

“We reached a point of impasse and couldn’t close the deal,’’ said the city’s attorney, Robert Alsop, of the law firm Kennedy and Graven, Minneapolis. Along with confirming that negotiations in the dispute between the city and Ansari have ended, Alsop said the city would again proceed with its lawsuit against him.

The lawsuit charges that Ansari’s four plastic-covered hoop structures violate city ordinances. It also charges that city ordinances prohibit him from selling the vegetables raised in them on his residential property.

Ansari disputes that he is in violation of the ordinances. He has divided the corner property into two tax parcels, and said the lots offer ample space to meet city ordinances regulating the number of secondary buildings and the percent of area they may occupy. He claims the hoop structures are raised beds, not buildings that fall under the city’s building ordinances.

He also counters that the city has no legal authority to prohibit him or anyone else from selling produce on their property.

Most of all, Ansari charges that he is being treated unfairly.

“All I’m asking is for equal rights. They should treat everybody equal,’’ said Ansari.

He claims that he is being singled out for prosecution due to his dark skin. To make his point, he maintains a Web site www.hoopbed.com on which he has posted a collection of photographs. They show a variety of activities in the community that he claims violate city ordinances, but for which no enforcement actions have been initiated.

His collection of photographs show nearly an entire city block within the city limits in which the land is tilled and used to raise corn and soybeans. The landowner, a longtime farmer, told Ansari that he has never been ordered to obtain a permit; nor would he consider asking for one from the city. Just a short walk from Ansari’s roadside stand, another resident has used vehicles for sale alongside the highway, two of them without engines. No permits have ever been issued for the roadside car lot, said Ansari.

Elsewhere in town, Ansari has taken photographs of lots where only garages or sheds are standing, allegedly in violation of a city ordinance requiring that secondary buildings be allowed only on lots with residences.

Ansari said he is prepared to tell the court that the city is “cherry picking’’ in selecting him for prosecution.

He also believes the court of public opinion will agree with him, pointing to a petition drive last year that collected 115 signatures in his support.

He has tracked the city’s legal bills for the past two years and tallied its legal expenses to the law firm of Kennedy and Graven at more than $32,000. Yet he said the city has not retained the Minneapolis law firm to enforce the law against others: He said there was an alleged assault at the Goose Bar in Watson earlier this year, but the city was advised to find a different law firm to prosecute the matter.

The city’s attorney steadfastly denies that the city has singled out Ansari. Alsop said the city has been prosecuting other violations in the community. It cannot prosecute all of the alleged violations all at one time, he said, adding that it has no obligations to do so in that manner either.

Ansari is without legal representation. A farm organization based in St. Paul initially took up his case, but said it did not have the resources to continue.

Former U.S. Attorney David Lillehaug took up his case pro bono, but withdrew as counsel earlier this year. Lillehaug had negotiated a possible agreement with the city that would have called for Ansari to dismantle two of the four raised beds.

But Ansari said the city also countered with a proposal that would have forced him to remove the farmer’s market sign, given the city ultimate say on where he could locate a table to accept “goodwill donations’’ for his produce, and required that he remove the plastic hoops during the non-growing season.

Ansari said there is an irony in all of this: A Hmong woman from St. Paul came and toured his hoops, and now has received grant funds to build the same and promote local food production in her urban neighborhood.

He argues that communities both large and small should be encouraging local food production and the very activity for which he faces a lawsuit.

“My aim is to bring this to the attention of the people,’’ said Ansari.

No court date has been set for the lawsuit.

Tags: newsregionwatsonazizansaritomatomanpermitlawsuitlocalfoodsfarm

14 comments

aziz a. Watson, MN     08/14/2009 10:25 AM

I read the article in the newspaper and wanted to thank Mr. Tom Cherveny and everybody at the West Central Tribune for bringing this matter to the forefront and helping bring public awareness to the growing concerns of growing more and more food. First of all I must correct a few things; I thank Jon T. in posting his comment and encouraging readers to visit my web site. Thank you Jon. However, the correct link would be www.hoopbed.com or simply Google hoopbed. The news article mentions that the City Attorney Mr. Alsop saying (pasted from the news article). The city’s attorney steadfastly denies that the city has singled out Ansari. Alsop said the city has been prosecuting other violations in the community. It cannot prosecute all of the alleged violations all at one time, he said, adding that it has no obligations to do so in that manner either. (End)
Another attorney from the same law firm Kennedy & Graven, Mr. Troy J. Gilchrist contradicts Mr. Alsop’s claim in his letter dated July 30, 2009 written to me. I have posted a copy of his letter on my web site https://sites.google.com/a/hoopbed.com/www/legal In my opinion Kennedy & Graven and the City of Watson should be investigated. I have ample proof of a broader conspiracy. As the Judge has mentioned in his memorandum that the court is troubled by the seemingly broad definition of “structure”. The City of Watson has never in its entire history applied this very ordinance to prosecute any resident where the City Attorney claims that a fence post is a structure. Have these people gone out of their minds or there is more then what the eye meets.
All I am asking is equal justice. Apply the ordinance across the board, pay attention to the Judge’s warning, listen to the residents of Watson. Stop wasting resident’s tax dollars. Respect my inherent constitutional right and stop subjecting me to constant harassment. Stop telling me where I should put a 4X8 table in my yard; it is my table and my yard, unless you think it is Watson, USSR and not Watson, USA.


Kelly B. Willmar, MN     08/13/2009 6:03 PM
Thank you reading this story's comments with wctrib.com. We have seen an increase in the number of readers' comments on stories, and people always tell us they keep coming back to see your reactions to the news. We are also see some individuals posting comments with inappropriate content, including name-calling, crude/profane language or personal abuse. Please help wctrib.com by clicking the "Report a Violation" link next to every comment posted on wctrib.com articles. This will send an e-mail to an editor, which helps speed the comment review process. Thank you for your assistance and for reading wctrib.com. - Tribune moderator

Jon T. Willmar, MN     08/13/2009 2:44 PM
I would really encourage everybody to check out his website. Google Watson/MN/Gardens and you'll find the page. It's very enlightening.
 
Craig H.
St. Paul/Woodbury, MN     08/13/2009 12:47 PM
I hope this guy at least proves the enforcement is suspect. If he's violating the ordanance, then he should make the adjustments necessary but only if the enforcement is being done across the board. This smells, I am looking forward to the testimony and outcome. My guess, things like this usually start with one bitter individual that doesn't like something about someone else (not necessarily their skin color either) and yelled the loudest. That seems to be the preferred method of problem solving these days.

betsy m.
Montevideo, MN     08/13/2009 11:45 AM
I agree with Julie. If the man bankrupted, which is public knowledge, and can't control his own spending why would he care what he spends with someone elses money. I'd be furious if he were spending mine in such a senseless manner. Leave the man alone. He has give many very valid points. It's hard enough to make a living but to have others more fortunate harrass him like that is senseless. It's not like he's living next to the White House.

Amber D.
Prinsburg, MN     08/13/2009 11:45 AM
Good luck Mr. Ansari, this whole lawsuit is absolutely asinine!! Since when is it illegal to have a garden and support your family! More people should be putting up green houses or supporting those who are selling there vegetables! Maybe our local economy would be better.....SHAME on the mayor for spending so much to prosecute this poor man!

Julie j.
Canby, MN     08/13/2009 11:11 AM
Look at all the wasted money spent here for the city of Watson. but, should we expect something more when the mayor himself has filed for personal bankruptcy recently? If he can't control his own spending habits, how can we expect him to make good smart judgements on other spendings? I'm happy this guy can make a living off of his garden and we don't have to support him! I think its time for the city of Watson to give up this fight, and quit wasting money!

Ron A.
Hanley Falls, MN     08/13/2009 9:00 AM
I wonder where the common sense went in this matter. It almost looks like someone has a personal grudge against this fellow. Maybe there should be a town meeting and find out just why the council and or mayor decides it is worth spending 32,000 for such a life and death issue. I think someone has to much time on their hands and needs to find a more worthy cause then what is being done.

Julie j.
Canby, MN     08/13/2009 8:28 AM
how much does the mayor of watson get paid? sounds like he needs to start doing his job, and quit wasting tax payer money on attorneys to go against this guy!!!

Julie j.
Canby, MN     08/13/2009 8:06 AM
Thats crazy - look at watson!! these things probably add to the city if nothing else! at least he has a job. leave him alone!!!

Mike S.
Willmar, MN     08/13/2009 8:03 AM

Good luck Mr. Ansari! I wonder how many signatures that he got were from people living in town? At least Watson has two places to buy liquor now, in your town of 200 poeple. Maybe he should have applied for a liquor license, they seem to hand those out, or maybe he can start an AA chapter!

Casey O.
Kerkhoven, MN     08/13/2009 7:52 AM
Leave him alone. $32,000 in legal bills. That's expensive produce.

Jon T.
Willmar, MN     08/13/2009 7:02 AM
Fight the good fight!

Lori L.
Rapid City, SD     08/13/2009 6:29 AM
The man makes some very valid points. And I would expect anyone within city limits in Watson who intends on having a garage sale on private property or anywhere else, must also obtain a permit to sell. It would be only right. For crying out loud, leave the man alone. Especially given our sorry state of economy we are in.
 
 
 
March 23' 2009                            NEWS ARTICLES COPIED FROM WEST CENTRAL TRIBUNE, WILLMAR, MN.
 
 
 

West Central Tribune

 
 
 
text size: zoom out zoom in     print article Print     e-mail article E-mail     share article Share
Published March 23 2009

Judge denies request to halt Watson’s legal action against vegetable grower

WATSON — A district judge has denied a request by Aziz Ansari to dismiss legal action against him by the city of Watson.

By: By Tom Cherveny, West Central Tribune

Aziz Ansari
Aziz Ansari is shown in this September file photo near the hoop structures where he raises vegetables on his residential lot alongside Minnesota Highway 7 in the city of Watson. Ansari and the city of Watson have gone to court to settle the question of whether the hoop structures violate city ordinance. (Tribune file photo by Tom Cherveny)

WATSON — A district judge has denied a request by Aziz Ansari to dismiss legal action against him by the city of Watson.

The recent order by District Judge David Mennis allows legal proceedings by the city of Watson against Ansari to continue. The city is asking the court to order Ansari to dismantle four plastic-covered hoop structures in which he raises vegetables for a seasonal, self-service farmers market.

But Ansari vows he will fight to continue raising tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers on his residential property, and said the judge’s recent ruling has only left him encouraged. While it may keep the city’s legal action against him moving forward, the memorandum by Judge Mennis also includes a clearly worded warning to the city.

Judge Mennis warns in his memorandum that if Ansari can show that he is being targeted unfairly by the city, especially as a minority person of color in the community, it opens itself up to state and federal claims by the defendant.

Ansari claims that the city of Watson has turned a blind eye to a wide range of planning ordinance violations and eyesores in the community that are far more egregious than what it alleges exist on his property. It’s a point that supporters of Ansari have repeatedly made to city officials as well, including at a public meeting in September.

“Indeed, if defendants can show that other Watson residents — especially those outside of Defendants’ protected class — have not been cited for violations of Plaintiff’s Zoning Ordinance for erecting other seemingly innocuous things on their properties that could be deemed ‘structures,’ it seems that Plaintiff is opening itself up to state or federal claims by Defendants too obvious to require elaboration,’’ wrote the judge.

Ansari’s legal dispute with the Chippewa County community dates to September, when the city filed the legal action alleging that he violated city ordinances by erecting four raised-bed structures that are 96 feet long and 6 feet wide. The city cites ordinances restricting the number of outbuildings allowed on residential lots and restrictions on how much area on a residential property can be occupied by buildings.

Ansari claims that his corner lot property — which he said includes two separate legal parcels — offers ample space to meet the requirements of the city’s ordinances. He also counters that the hoop structures are not “buildings’’ as claimed by the city, and that he has a right to sell vegetable produce.

Ansari had initially obtained pro bono legal help from a farmer’s rights group based in St. Paul, but it has since informed him that it does not have the resources to continue representing him. Ansari represented himself during a Feb. 25 hearing in Montevideo on his request to have the legal action dismissed.

The city of Watson has retained attorney Robert Alan Alsop with the Minneapolis law firm of Kennedy and Gravens.

Ansari said he has found support in the region from proponents of local foods. They’d like to make it easier for people to raise their own food, and revise ordinances that now make it difficult or impossible to do so. They have set up a Web site “Justice for Tomato Man’’ to tell the story. It can be found at: http://www.hoopbed.com/Home.

Tags: newsregionwatsonvegetablegrowermarketzoning

 
Account | Logout      Monday, March 23, 2009

West Central Tribune

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

 Here are all the comments people had on the newspaper artcles


Account
 | Logout      Tuesday, March 23, 2009

 

 

· 

Judge denies request to halt Watson’s legal action against vegetable grower 

By By Tom Cherveny, West Central Tribune

Recent Comments

1 2 3 next »

Don A.
Fargo, ND     03/23/2009 11:45 PM

Marks comment was Well said.

Report a Violation

Mark T.
Milan, MN     03/23/2009 10:43 PM

Now that Michelle Obama has started a vegetable garden on the White House grounds, the Justice Department will no doubt be taking legal action against her for some outdated, obscure rule. Good sense, be damned! Rather than legal action against Mr. Ansari, the city officials might have considered amending their statute on commercial gardens on residential property, considering the "blossoming" local foods movement and the economic recession/depression. Even at this point, a little resiliency/flexibility/creativity on the part of the Watson government would be welcomed, I'm sure.

Report a Violation

aziz a.
Watson, MN     03/23/2009 5:56 PM

Mr. Todd this is for you, The constitution of the state of Minnesota, grants mr. Ansari to grow and sell produce on his property (see Minn. Const. art. XIII, 7 ("any person may sell or peddle the products of the farm or garden occupied and cultivated by him without obtaining a license therefor"); State v. Hartman, 700 N. W. 2d 499 (2005) (holding that products of the farm or garden "may be sold by farmers without obtaining a license to do so," and affirming that "[b]eing relieved of the need to obtain a license therefore allows farmers to sell the products of their farm without obtaining the government's permission.") (Emphasis in original). how about other people who have sold vegetables from their backyard right on hwy. 7 some 4 blocks from me, like Mr. Danny Larson, city never asked him for a permit, Even the mayor of watson runs a business out of his home, talk about double standards, please see my site http://www.hoopbed.com/updates and read about mr. todd vogel, and Watson, he is the new Mr. Zoning Commissioner of Watson

Report a Violation

Carie L.
Granite Falls
, MN     03/23/2009 5:31 PM

Todd - do you know, has the city of Watson attempted to rezone a portion of the property, to work with the man so he can then run a business on his property.... like the Farmer's Market he seems to want to run? Or tried to work with the man to meet the ordinances? Yes, there are two sides to every story - I would like to hear both sides. if you can help with that, I would appreciate it.

Report a Violation

Jeffrey J.
Anchorage, AK     03/23/2009 4:02 PM

What did this guy do to P_$$ off the ignorant city leaders? I can not believe in this day and age people who are supposed to be civic leaders make such a stupid decision about this person or is it that they are doing this solely on the fact that he is a outsider? What is going on in Mn. NICE have the leaders all lost their sense on what is the right thing to do or is it let see how miserable we can make some people be because they don't look or have a Scandinavian name? What a waste of tax payer money but I guess they will use stimulus money for this adventure in stupidity.

Report a Violation

Todd V.
Watson, MN     03/23/2009 3:49 PM

Every story has 2 sides, and any city or town has ordinances. It is not the fact that he has a garden it is what he does with it, the R1 ordinance states NO COMMERCIAL GARDENS, you may have a garden for your own use. He was approved to have one hoop garden! 

Report a Violation

Laurie G.
Olivia, MN     03/23/2009 2:16 PM

Maybe the judge denied the request, but gave the city of Watson a 'warning' as a subtle message to 'drop the whole thing before you have real trouble'? Scandi's are known to be stubborn and untrusting - most have moved past it, but people who spend their lives in small towns live in a very small world and carry on those 'traditions' to the point of embarrassment. Mr. Borg started the whole mess, yet, as I understand, he runs a repiar business out of his garage - with no permit. Watson city council, and Mr Borg, are wrong and should be ashamed of themselves...I'm sure they know it, but they are too damnd stubborn to admit they are wrong.

Report a Violation

Carie L.
Granite Falls
, MN     03/23/2009 2:09 PM

Watson could be choosing to capatalize on Mr. Ansari's unique approach, and efforts to help those in need. Instead, the city of Watson is choosing to bring negative attention to itself - I wouldn't think that's what the city would want. If it's a matter of zoning, or the kind of buildings on the property, it would serve the city better to offer to assist Mr. Ansari in meeting ordinance requirements, rather than setting themselves up as an adversary. It's too bad that this couldn't have been resolved, with a bit more good will and cooperation.

Report a Violation

gary l.
Reston, VA     03/23/2009 1:48 PM

The picture is an interesting juxtaposition; i.e., the image of a person of foreign origin and his garden and the sign of the Watson Evangelical ..... church. Wonder what side of this argument the church and/or its members are on.

Report a Violation

Casey O.
Kerkhoven, MN     03/23/2009 11:46 AM

I wished I could afford to build covered gardens like he has. That would extend the growing season. The pictures on the web site looked very nice. I didn't see an eyesore, I saw a very nice garden.

Report a Violation

David M.
Clara City
, MN     03/23/2009 11:35 AM

My goodness, let the guy grow his veggies! Why don't the city do something more important with their time!

Report a Violation

joan r.
Pennock, MN     03/23/2009 11:31 AM

Herbert D. of Sauk Centre . Gotta love this one, Read it 2 times to figure out what you said. Tongue in cheek sarcasm. I wonder if every one understood it Where is the common sense of the city council in Watson? Must be relatives of the idiots in Willmar. Remember S. Wagar? STOP putting race into every move Leeann. Move on to stupid people who just can't grow anything & resent those who can. I will just have to drive out there to get some of his vegetables. 

Report a Violation

LeeAnn V.
Kerkhoven, MN     03/23/2009 10:07 AM

this is racism, pure and simple.

Report a Violation

Renee M.
Kerkhoven, MN     03/23/2009 10:03 AM

i have not heard one negative thing said so far!!where are those people? speak up! no they wont because they know its racist and they are just plain dumb for doing this. i wish i was closer to buy his fresh veggies.

Report a Violation

LeeAnn V.
Kerkhoven, MN     03/23/2009 9:54 AM

this is racism, pure and simple.

Report a Violation

Julie D.
New London, MN     03/23/2009 9:10 AM

Oh for pity's sake... I just looked at the pictures on the website. That is not a building, it's a garden. A covered garden. I wish I had such a nice garden. What in the world is getting into people????? Let the man grow his veggies.

Report a Violation

Darin V.
Sioux Falls, SD     03/23/2009 8:39 AM

Anyone who has driven through Watson (does anyone drive TO Watson?) could tell you there are more obvious eyesores than someone's seasonal vegetable garden hoops. Good luck to Mr. Ansari!

Report a Violation

Pat H.
Benson, MN     03/23/2009 8:35 AM

I sure hope Watson gets no state LGA as it seems it would be a waste of dollars!

Jon T.
Willmar, MN     03/23/2009 8:30 AM

Watson needs a wake-up call to the fact that the good old boys days of doing things are over.

Report a Violation

herbert d.
Sauk Centre, MN     03/23/2009 7:29 AM

If the vegetables will help feed the people of Mn who might want fresh locally grown food, then we need to stamp this out before it spreads! We need more subsidies for corporate farms not some local guy growing food!This is America! God Bless

Report a Violation

lynn w.
Spicer, MN     03/23/2009 7:27 AM

seems the judicial participants are making too many "trips" to the police property room on break...

Report a Violation

brian g.
Minneapolis, MN     03/23/2009 6:49 AM

This case is definitely as strange as the Willmar city attorney's non-action against the juvenile homecoming vandals. I have to agree with all three of the previous posters. I guess I would use a little stronger wording than "messed up" for this non-city (small village at best). Now wait, please don't be offended by this. Even though my moniker lists my address as "minneapolis", I have the deepest respect (and admiration) for the fortunate among us who can live in small communities. I have lived in both, but thoroughly enjoy living in a rural area more. Having said that, anyone with a brain has to admit that a totally different mindset exists between people who have lived in urban areas the majority of their lives and countryfolk. More people in rural areas just cannot accept the tenet of "accepting anything as long as it doesn't negatively affect someone else, live and let live". It's called freedom. I have read all I can about this case and nowhere have I seen where someone has stated the goal of the village of Watson.

Report a Violation

Mark D.
Lake Lillian
, MN     03/23/2009 6:36 AM

Does Watson really have the resourses to fight this? If so maybe they should use these resourses in a more productive way. Maybe build a community vegetable farm on a couple vacant lots that give the produce away. Seems the best way to put him out of business would be through competition. Or maybe help him build his business so more people would visit Watson and maybe shop at some of the other stores. I haven't been to Watson for a few years but if it is like all the other small comunities is Minnesota, any business is better than none.

Report a Violation

Randy O.
Hoffman, MN     03/23/2009 6:06 AM

Watson is one messed up city.

Report a Violation

Craig H.
Willmar, MN     03/23/2009 5:18 AM

I hope this guy wins. If his structures do not pose safety hazards and are not eyesores, let the guy grow and sell his stuff... you'd think a small town would want more people like him keeping money in the community. Driving through there a few times, I have no doubt he has a point about the city letting other structures pass.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________

Recent Comments

Laurie G.
Olivia, MN     03/23/2009 2:35 PM

Geee....do you think maybe these small town councils and sheriff's departments will soon realize that they can't apply the rules to one while ignoring others? 

lynn w.
Spicer, MN     03/23/2009 8:23 AM

good. at least he doesn't have to worry about how much justice he can afford...

Report a Violation

Craig H.
Willmar, MN     03/23/2009 5:30 AM

I agree, good luck with your dispute. I hope you and the city can come to a reasonable agreement for both sides.

Report a Violation

 ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
 
March 23' 2009
 
Please click the link below to read the news article in the West Central Tribune, Willmar, MN.